Minister Zwarycz, the new Einstein (Dr. Walter Prochorenko)
06/12/2005 | Sztefan von Seitz
Letter to E-Poshta,
Re: Justice Minister Zvarych debate TOP
The Roman Zvarych issue is only a minor element of the fundamental questions that divide us and prevent us from gaining focus.
I read with great interest Myhaijlo Brytans letter to the editor (June 5th, 2005) regarding the ongoing controversy surrounding Minister of Justice Roman Zvarychs educational credentials. Rather than fanning the flames of controversy any further (which I would find to be counterproductive since the Ministers brother is a friend and the Kyiv Post editor Andrey Slivka is the son of another friend), I would like to bring to the readers attention to the fact that some of the most brilliant minds known to man also had problems with their degrees. It is a well known fact that the great Albert Einstein failed to obtain his initial engineering diploma in 1895 from the Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule in Zurich, but did this diminish his accomplishments?
I had the pleasure of listening to Mr. Zvarych's several speeches during his visit to NY in March 2005, and although somewhat controversial and perhaps undiplomatic, Mr. Zvarych made a tremendous impact on his audience and his listeners whether they agreed with him or not. There is no doubt in my mind that Mr. Zvarych is a most patriotic Ukrainian, completely loyal and supportive of his president, and a tremendous asset to his chosen country. Many people in Ukraine and in the US found it strange that Mr. Zvarych denounced his US citizenship for that of a Ukrainian one, but how many of us in the diaspora have chosen citizenships other than those into which we were born. I for one already had three and given the opportunity would probably have had chosen more. Perhaps I'm being too simplistic, but in a global world citizenship is becoming similar to rooting for your favorite citys sports team.
What I do find very disturbing about this controversy is that most Ukrainians still have not found the capacity to stick together and be supportive of each other regardless of such controversies. I always watch in wonderment how the small Jewish society can use the positive elements of its connectivity to create a worldwide network unlike any other known to mankind. Is there nothing that can be learned from this? Why do some Ukrainians still try to undermine the greatness and the spectacular success of the Orange Revolution? Is there some kind of self-destructive mechanism in our psyche?
The Roman Zvarych issue is only a minor element of the fundamental questions that divide us and prevent us from gaining focus. The divisions evident in Ukraines political hierarchy are also troubling to me and could prevent Ukraines governing bodies from pursuing the mandates of their people. We in the diaspora, because of our distance from day to day events, have the luxury and capacity of being objective in our view of Ukraines quest for true self determination. Would it not benefit Ukraine if we use this objectivity to guide rather than judge what its government is trying to achieve? For the most part we certainly cannot change it so would it not behoove us to support it?
Walter Prochorenko, PhD.
Paramus, NJ.
Re: Justice Minister Zvarych debate TOP
The Roman Zvarych issue is only a minor element of the fundamental questions that divide us and prevent us from gaining focus.
I read with great interest Myhaijlo Brytans letter to the editor (June 5th, 2005) regarding the ongoing controversy surrounding Minister of Justice Roman Zvarychs educational credentials. Rather than fanning the flames of controversy any further (which I would find to be counterproductive since the Ministers brother is a friend and the Kyiv Post editor Andrey Slivka is the son of another friend), I would like to bring to the readers attention to the fact that some of the most brilliant minds known to man also had problems with their degrees. It is a well known fact that the great Albert Einstein failed to obtain his initial engineering diploma in 1895 from the Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule in Zurich, but did this diminish his accomplishments?
I had the pleasure of listening to Mr. Zvarych's several speeches during his visit to NY in March 2005, and although somewhat controversial and perhaps undiplomatic, Mr. Zvarych made a tremendous impact on his audience and his listeners whether they agreed with him or not. There is no doubt in my mind that Mr. Zvarych is a most patriotic Ukrainian, completely loyal and supportive of his president, and a tremendous asset to his chosen country. Many people in Ukraine and in the US found it strange that Mr. Zvarych denounced his US citizenship for that of a Ukrainian one, but how many of us in the diaspora have chosen citizenships other than those into which we were born. I for one already had three and given the opportunity would probably have had chosen more. Perhaps I'm being too simplistic, but in a global world citizenship is becoming similar to rooting for your favorite citys sports team.
What I do find very disturbing about this controversy is that most Ukrainians still have not found the capacity to stick together and be supportive of each other regardless of such controversies. I always watch in wonderment how the small Jewish society can use the positive elements of its connectivity to create a worldwide network unlike any other known to mankind. Is there nothing that can be learned from this? Why do some Ukrainians still try to undermine the greatness and the spectacular success of the Orange Revolution? Is there some kind of self-destructive mechanism in our psyche?
The Roman Zvarych issue is only a minor element of the fundamental questions that divide us and prevent us from gaining focus. The divisions evident in Ukraines political hierarchy are also troubling to me and could prevent Ukraines governing bodies from pursuing the mandates of their people. We in the diaspora, because of our distance from day to day events, have the luxury and capacity of being objective in our view of Ukraines quest for true self determination. Would it not benefit Ukraine if we use this objectivity to guide rather than judge what its government is trying to achieve? For the most part we certainly cannot change it so would it not behoove us to support it?
Walter Prochorenko, PhD.
Paramus, NJ.
Відповіді
2005.06.12 | kolia
Re: Minister Zwarycz, the new Einstein (Dr. Walter Prochorenko)
По англецкому, так по англецкому:Dear Mr. Prochorenko:
If you try to find and read all the articles in Ukrainian press related to the issue, you will realize that Minister Zwarycz is a shameless liar. Einstein, the one you are comparing Zwarycz to, has never distorted any facts about his education. The fact that Zwarycz denounced his American citizenship doesn’t mean anything. He just realized that he wouldn’t achieve much in the US of A with his stinky Manhattan College diploma.
2005.06.12 | Sztefan von Seitz
фідбек можна слати осюда:
Editor, Political Affairs:Larissa Hotra lmhotra@gmail.com
а також:
Editor-in-Chief:
Myroslava Oleksiuk myroslava@rogers.com
ADMINISTRATION, subscribing, unsubscribing, etc. TOP
Myroslava Oleksiuk
-- editor-in-chief
Larissa Hotra
-- editor, political affairs
Paul Horbal
-- editor, business report
-- story layout
Anya Maziak
-- editor, events, arts & letters
Oleksiy Hryshyn
-- membership
-- technical support
Zenon Chytra
-- story layout
Bohdan Nakonieczny
-- story layout
Ihor Prociuk
-- story layout and design
We hope you found e-POSHTA informative and will share it with others.
Your submissions and suggestions are always welcome.
Myroslava_e-poshta-canadaus@yahoogroups.com
or
myroslava@rogers.com
Use the following e-mail addresses to:
SEND us e-mail:
Myroslava_e-poshta-canadaus@yahoogroups.com
JOIN the list:
Myroslava_e-poshta-canadaus-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
QUIT the list:
Myroslava_e-poshta-canadaus-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
YahooGroups will send you an e-mail--to which you must reply--in order to confirm that you want to quit the list. This is done to prevent someone faking your e-mail address and deleting you from the list without your knowledge.
Membership
Having difficulty joining (or quitting) the list? Or maybe you want us to add your friends to e-POSHTA? Contact:
Oleksiy Hryshyn ask_e_poshta@sympatico.ca
Editor-in-Chief:
Myroslava Oleksiuk myroslava@rogers.com
Editor, Political Affairs:
Larissa Hotra lmhotra@gmail.com
Editor, Business Report:
Paul Horbal horbal@gmail.com
Editor, Events, Arts & Letters:
Anya Maziak amaziak@yahoo.com
Events, conferences, and employment:
Send announcements at least two weeks before the event date. If you maintain a web-based list of events for your city or region, let us know. We will add a link to your site from the e-POSHTA newsletter.
e_poshta_events@yahoo.ca
See the guidelines for submitting event announcements.
Layout:
Ihor Prociuk prociuki@yahoo.com
Zenon Chytra zchytra@cogeco.ca
Bohdan Nakonieczny bnakonieczny@sympatico.ca
Paul Horbal horbal@gmail.com
Technical Support:
Oleksiy Hryshyn: ask_e_poshta@sympatico.ca